It’s Friday night, the crowd is large inside the Viking Theater at Grandview University in Des Moines, Iowa. I’m ready to perform. I’ve practiced hard, and I’m confident. At poetry slams, you draw a card to determine the order of performances. I’m number 3. Five judges are on the panel: Paul Brooke, Dawn Terpstra, Caleb the Negro Artist Rainey, Jennifer Knox, and Leah Waughtal-Magiera.

It’s my turn and I perform my poem with emotion and energy. By the end, the crowd is laughing, applauding loudly, and I feel really happy about my performance. When I get to my seat, the gentleman sitting next to me congratulates me and says, “You rocked it!” The judges’ ratings are verbally reported, and sadly my ratings are not all that great. My highest score is 9.4 and my lowest is an 8.1. Nuts!

My goal for this event was to make it into the second round. I really had two other powerful poems I wanted to share. As I sat listening to the other poets, I kept debating about which one would be best. I thought I had a good chance of moving on, but it seemed like the judges began to rank people higher after my performance.

Who understands how these things happen, but when they say goodbye to the people who will not advance, I’m on the list. My heart sinks. I feel stupid and like a complete loser. I am also perturbed because two people who advanced, I believe did not perform as well as I did. For the second year in a row, I do not advance. I’d already decided I would not do a slam again, but now this decision is firmly sealed.

Last night I woke up around 2 in the morning and it was my failure to advance was my first thought. I am truly struggling to let this go, but I know this is disappointment is not a big deal considering things that really matter. It’s just a big deal in my mind. Who the heck gave me the 8.1 is my big question. Why so low? I have thoughts that my age is a reason. More and more I feel impacted by ageism biases in society.

I am also haunted by the fact that I realize I was four seconds over time which gave me a .04 reduction in score. Had I had those points, I would have advanced. So now I can just be unhappy with myself, again feeling like a failure wondering how I went over time. I practiced so hard three different poems. I keep second guessing myself. Maybe if I should have done that poem or that poem, and if I had I would have been performing in the second round.

One thing that helps assuage the pain was the fact that so many people commented on my performance the next day when I attended the Poetry Palooza workshops. One lady said that I inspired her. She said my performance made her believe she could also compete. (Yes, she is a person of age, too). The best part occurred in the afternoon when I attended Deb Marquart’s session on writing eco poetry. I have been a fan of her poetry since the early 90s. I shared that with her and asked her to sign her newest released book. She wrote me the best note ever, and so even though I’ll probably still feel like a complete loser for months, I can open her book and feel some pride about my last poetry slam performance.

I'm sharing the poem I performed. Thanks for reading my blog today:)

my father was an angry man,
an angry, angry man
and who could blame him
five kids, really six, a daughter
who left him for her adopted father

his divorce made front page news
his wife, he said, was crazy jealous
he couldn’t live that way

later he married my mother
a round faced 5 foot two woman
he described as pleasantly plump
an angel really
stricken with disease at 36
bed-bound until her death at 60

so who wouldn’t be angry with
an invalid wife
five kids at home to feed
five feral scrappy kids
always fighting
we learned to endure his wrath
learned to tread carefully,
so often full of fear,
fear of his attention, his path of destruction
we were the ruins of his life

and he was always full of advice

I remember once he tried to tell me
I could do better
I could be on the top step
that the boy I was seeing
was the bottom step
yeah, he kinda was,
but the top step
never
I never could commit
to such high stakes
I Just wanted to be loved
feel loved
maybe even worshiped
a little

and after my mother passed
he started dating
a whirlwind of women
that had our heads spinning
and all that advice he’d given
was quickly forgotten

I remember my sister’s story,
how she got a call from a mall cop
there was a situation she had to help fix
my sister who was due with twins any day
had to go to the mall
to find that my Dad had fallen
and was drunk
when she got there she heard the cop say,
Richard, do you know you’re wearing two ties?
damn right, I know I’m wearing two ties

you see my dad was color blind
needed his girlfriend’s advice
about which tie looked right
a girlfriend that wasn’t so nice

after all these years remembering
the fear he instilled
I just want to tell him,
Dad, you could have done so much better
you could have been on the top step
that woman you were dating was on the bottom step
but I know he just wanted to be loved
feel loved
maybe even worshiped
a little

Barb Edler Avatar

Published by

Categories:

18 responses to “Slammed: My Big Fat Disappointment”

  1. Terje Avatar
    Terje

    First of all I am at awe. Your poem and the fact that you participate in poetry slams makes me applaud to you. Today I watched an interview with European Poetry Slam winner and when the interviewer asked “How can anyone judge poems?”, the winner answered “The same way we judge music, you can’t really judge objectively, who knows what determines the result.” Keep writing, keep participating, keep inspiring others to also participate.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Barb Edler Avatar

      Thank you for your encouragement!

      Like

  2. edifiedlistener Avatar

    I hear your disappointment so clearly. You are brave to slam and perform at that level – acts for which I have only respect and admiration. The poem is strong and personal and I’m sure reached those who heard it. Thank you for sharing the poem here and offering us a taste of your performance.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Denise Krebs Avatar
    Denise Krebs

    Barb, oh my goodness. You are such a strong voice in this space and beyond. Thank you for sharing your broken hearted disappointment. I love to hear your passion in your prose and poetry. The poem about your dad is stellar! And, oh, my, that comment can last a good long time. A lot of people could say they are fans of your work. Like me. Thanks for sharing!

    Like

  4. Glenda Funk Avatar

    Barb,

    I know you’re leaning into all the feelings right now, and I get it. I wanted to go to Georgia w/ you. I wish I’d been in Iowa last weekend. But I have to say this: I want you to grab onto the note in that book, and if you have to fake it for a while, then do it. You want get a replay of that specific moment, but that poem and how it speaks to so many comes from a voice that our generation, as well as younger people, need to hear. Don’t go back to the silence, my friend. Take a step higher and then another. Reading the poem about your father sparked a memory, a time when I saw my mother in jail. I’m sure she was there because she’d gotten drunk and into a bar room brawl. My sister and I went looking for her, probably because we were hungry. We found her in jail and went away hungrier. I remember that because you made that memory rise, and I think I need that. I also see this post as the seed for a new spoken word poem–when you’re ready.

    Like

    1. Barb Edler Avatar

      Oh my gosh, Glenda. I so appreciate your encouragement and sharing your own story about finding your mother in jail. Gosh, I can’t even imagine the difficulty you faced at such a young age. Thanks for always listening to me with your heart! Your support is deeply appreciated!

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Fran McCrackin Avatar

    I am so impressed by your guts to participate in slams. Good on you. And your strength- both in this slice and in your poem- is your willingness to truly be honest. Such strong writing, you bring us all along on your portrayal of feelings. Your poem uses that switch in perspective so well, and using the same lines is so, so powerful. You show us anger and love, resentment and understanding, all in a short poem. “You could be on the top step” was a loving thing for him to tell you, and a line I will remember.

    Like

    1. Barb Edler Avatar

      Fran, thank you so much for your generous words. I deeply appreciate your support.

      Like

  6. Diane Anderson (newtreemom) Avatar

    I was in awe of your participation in the poetry slam. The disappointment was bitter to me, too. The awe in comments people shared and the note… oh, that note. Yet all that was a murmur in the background as I read your poem. What courage and kindness in sharing that story. All of us who’ve experienced difficult times with parents (such as Glenda also shared, such as I, too, lived with an alcoholic father and an angry mother who got angrier and more bitter) know how we need to hear, need to share the stories to find meaning and healing, to find the understanding… and the love. Thank you. Whatever you may decide about the poetry slam, please keep sharing the poetry.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Barb Edler Avatar

      Diane, thank you for your thoughtful encouraging words.

      Like

  7. wordancerblog Avatar

    Barb – your poetry always touches me in profound ways. Your words nudge me to do better, try a little more, be a bit more open and daring. I, too, had an angry father. He is 98 and still angry. I’ve tried everything to please him, but everything is not enough so I let go and went my own way. I used to do poetry readings in college. I was petrified but always felt so much accomplishment when I had finished. I never presented in a poetry slam. But now you are nudging me again. Thank you!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Barb Edler Avatar

      Joanne, thanks for sharing. I know how hard it can be to please someone who just isn’t happy. I hope you will perform your poetry again. Your work is vibrant and needs to be shared.

      Liked by 1 person

  8. kimhaynesjohnson Avatar

    Barb, you ARE stellar! I love those words to you in writing. You are an inspiration, an artist, and you are clearly no failure. You have guts and gusto, and you give it your all. Your poem is amazing, but it’s YOU who wins the prize. I have to say that I have felt “less than” when the energy of the younger person is beside me, but the truth is that there is a demeanor and a wisdom that keeps the passion on an even keel when we have lived our experiences, and I think that is what the judges see – judges who do not yet understand the truths of our voice. Not age, but maturity and wisdom and the way we’ve processed it all. Nothing alarms those of us who’ve seen a lot more than those youngsters on stage. Please , whatever you do, don’t let this seal the deal. Keep writing, keep reciting, keep slamming!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Barb Edler Avatar

      I appreciate your uplifting encouragement, Kim!

      Like

  9. Maureen Young Ingram Avatar

    Barb, you are being much too hard on yourself. We are our worst critics. From where I sit in Maryland, you rock! You are daring to do this, wrestling with how, practicing your butt off, and yes – it’s going to suck sometimes to hear the scores, but can’t you try to hold the ‘high’ you feel while doing it? Hold the praise you are hearing? Your poem is awesome – so raw, such truth-telling…a real sign that you are tough, been down and out, and choose to fly, to soar. I bet you’ll look at this differently in a few more days; I hope you will.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Barb Edler Avatar

      Thank you, Maureen. I don’t think my viewpoint will change, but as time goes by the hurt will lessen I’m sure.

      Like

  10. juliemckelly4 Avatar

    You are brave and courageous. Keep sharing.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to juliemckelly4 Cancel reply